Women in the arts
Women in the arts CHAPTER 4
Women in the arts
Women in the arts CHAPTER 4
1
Many depictions of women, few women artists…
Anne Vallayer-Coster, Still life with sea plume, shells and lithophytes,
1769, oil on canvas, 130 x 97 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/René-Gabriel Ojeda
Marie-Denise Villers, A Study of a Woman from Nature, also known as Portrait of Madame Soustra,
1802, oil on canvas, 146 x 114 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Jean-Gilles Berizzi
Barbara Longhi, Madonna and Child Crowning a Nun,
late 16th/early 17th century, oil on canvas, 39 x 32 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Adrien Didierjean
Marguerite Gérard, The Interesting Student,
circa 1786, oil on canvas, 65 x 54 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Mathieu Rabeau

A bit like the National Museum of Fine Arts in Algiers, which lacked works by Algerian artists, the majority of museums lack works by women artists… even today!

 

 

In France in 2021, works of art produced by women represented only 4% of the total in museum collections.

 

And in 2012, the activist group Guerrilla Girls highlighted that less than 4% of artists in the Modern and Contemporary Art department at The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York are women… while women represent 76% of the nudes on display!

 

 

Why such a high proportion of female nudes? Well, for a very long time male artists (for whom it was easier to be a professional artist than it was for women) produced works for male patrons. And these patrons’ tastes leaned more towards female subjects, often with a touch of eroticism.

Poster for Guerrilla Girls, Conscience of the Art World,
2012, DR
In a nutshell

In museum collections, there are few works by female artists but many works depicting women.

2
Passive models?

Who are the women depicted in the works, or the “models”, as we call them?

 

First of all, they could be the patron of the work, therefore belonging to the wealthiest sectors of society. This is the case, for example, with the famous Mona Lisa.

 

The identity of the model has been debated at length, but it is very probably Lisa del Giocondo, the wife of a wealthy Florentine cloth merchant.

 

She is so popular today that she appears as a guest star in a Jay-Z and Beyoncé music video.

Leonardo da Vinci, Mona Lisa,
1503–1519, oil on wood, 80 x 53 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Michel Urtado
The Carters (Beyoncé & Jay-Z), Apeshit (image taken from the music video),
2018
Their sister: Gustave Courbet, Portrait of his sister Juliette Courbet as a child, sleeping,
circa 1841, lead pencil, 19 x 22 cm, d’Orsay Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (d’Orsay Museum)/Tony Querrec
Their companion: Pierre-Paul Prud’hon, Portrait of Miss Mayer, painter,
late 18th century, pastel, 41 x 32 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Martine Beck-Coppola
Their mother-in-law: Jacques-Louis David, Madame Charles-Pierre Pécoul, née Potain, mother-in-law of the artist,
1784, oil on canvas, 92 x 72 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre)

 

When not working on a commission, artists often made do with the models they had to hand… their nearest and dearest!

 

  • Their sister,
  • Their partner,
  • Their mother-in-law.

 

Professional models were first used in private studios, and then in painting academies, where life drawing sessions would take place.

 

To paint this picture, Corot called upon Emma Dobigny, a renowned professional model who had already posed for other painters such as Edgar Degas and Édouard Manet!

 

In any case, “model” does not necessarily mean “passive” – some became genuine advisers, at a time when the artist was usually alone in front of their canvas. An outside perspective is welcome sometimes!

Camille Corot, The Lady in Blue,
1874, oil on canvas, 80 x 50 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Adrien Didierjean
In a nutshell

The models who posed for works may have been the patrons themselves, people close to the artist, or professional models.

3
Representations of musicians and dancers: a reality that truly existed
Let’s take a look at music now.

Women have been practising their art in this domain for ages! Let’s look at a few instruments that date back to ancient times:

Statue of Henoutideh, singer for Amon, holding a sistrum / Sistrum adorned with the head of the goddess Hathor,
Statue: between 1424 and 1400, sandstone, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Christian Décamps / Sistrum: between 664 and 332 BCE, bronze, 28 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Christian Décamps

Sistrum:

This instrument from ancient Egypt is held in the hand and shaken. The noise made by the rings on the crossbars often accompanied processions in honour of the goddesses Isis and Hathor. It is the latter, recognisable by her cow ears, that can be seen on the handle of this sistrum.

Figurine from Susa / Triangular harp
Figurine: between 305 BCE and 224, clay, 9 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Thierry Ollivier / Harp: between 808 and 766 BCE, wood and leather, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Hervé Lewandowski

Harp:
This kind of triangular harp was almost exclusively used by women.

Wall painting from Pompeii (detail) / Lyre
between 62 and 79 CE, mortar, 52 x 40 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Hervé Lewandowski / Hervé Lewandowski / Lyre: between 62 and 79, mortar, 52 x 40 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Hervé Lewandowski
Lyre:
The lyre is a member of harp family, which is also a plucked string instrument but differs in shape from its big sister.
Figurine from Eretria / Egyptian tambourine
Figurine: between 300 and 250 BCE, clay, 27 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Hervé Lewandowski/ Tambourine: between 798 and 760 BCE, wood and leather, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Hervé Lewandowski

Tambourine:
The figure of the tambourine dancer was commonly depicted in Ancient Greece, and remains of these instruments have also been found in Egypt!

Concert in a garden / Moroccan spike vielle
Concert: 18th century, gouache, 30 x 20 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Claire Tabbagh/Digital Collections / Vielle :circa 1832, wood, iron, leather, coconut wood, 91 cm, Eugène-Delacroix National Museum, Paris. © 2016 Louvre Museum/Georges Poncet

Vielle:

The instrument held by the central figure resembles a kind of vielle, a stringed instrument played with a bow… a bit like a violin!

In a nutshell

Depictions of female musicians and musical instruments bear witness to their existence, particularly in antiquity.

4
Vice and virtue in the practice of music

 

Wishing to disqualify a woman he identified as a threat, in antiquity a Roman politician said that she sang and danced more skilfully than was necessary for an honest woman. What did he really mean?

 

It demonstrates the ambivalent regard in which female musicians and dancers were often held.

 

On the one hand, music was considered a “high art”, especially when practised in certain circumstances, such as during religious ceremonies or privately in artistic lessons.

 

Jean-Honoré Fragonard, The Music Lesson,
1765–1770, oil on canvas, 109 x 121 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Franck Raux
Roman relief of a libation scene,
1st century CE, marble, 50 x 62 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Hervé Lewandowski
The Colmar Painter, Cup with red figure,
490 BCE, clay, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Hervé Lewandowski

 

But sometimes there is a fine line between artistic practices like these, and what some consider acts of debauchery or vice!

 

In antiquity, highly cultured courtesans called “hetairai” entertained the men they accompanied with music and dance. For some, these arts were close to being a vice, associated with their profession as prostitutes.

Decorative Roman plaque called Campana,
early 1st century, clay, 43 x 28 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © Louvre Museum, Dist. RMN-Grand Palais/Hervé Lewandowski

 

In Greek mythology, maenads (known as “Bacchantes” by Romans) are female figures associated with debauchery, who joyfully indulge in the pleasures of dance and music.

In a nutshell

The practice of music by women is considered virtuous under certain conditions and associated with vice in others.

5
The role of benefactors
Leonardo da Vinci, Portrait of Isabella d’Este,
1499–1500, drawing, 61 x 47 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Michel Urtado

The name Isabelle d’Este may not mean anything to you yet, but she had such a profound influence in 15th-century Italy that she was given the nickname the “First Lady of the Renaissance”!

 

 

Why such an honour? Her role as patron meant that she used her fortune to support the work of artists by, for example, commissioning works. This allowed painters like Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo and Andrea Mantegna to make ends meet.

 

As an added bonus, Isabelle d’Este took over the reins of government on several occasions when her husband was absent. It was no problem for this gutsy woman who knew a thing or two about politics and geopolitics!

 

Andrea Mantegna, Mars and Venus, also known as The Parnassus,
late 15th century, tempera on canvas, 160 x 183 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo © RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Stéphane Maréchalle
In a nutshell

Female benefactors like the Italian Isabelle d’Este had a major influence on artistic and political life.

6
Few names of female women artists are known to us, but history is not set in stone…
Rosalba Carriera Giovanna, Portrait of a young girl holding a monkey,
first half of the 18th century, pastel, 62 x 48 cm, Louvre Museum, Paris. Photo (C) RMN-Grand Palais (Louvre Museum)/Michel Urtado

As you’ve learnt during this journey, while women feature heavily in works of art, fewer have been recognised as professional artists. That doesn’t mean that they didn’t exist, though, and some have even garnered an international reputation!

 

Some managed to earn their living and become famous renowned thanks to their artistic endeavours, such as Vigée-Le Brun, Rosalba Carriera and others.

 

History is still being written! We must bear in mind that many of the oldest works are not signed, and could just as well have been produced by women.

 

Let’s not forget that many women worked in family studios that bore the name of their father or husband.

 

It’s not easy to untangle everything, but historians continue to carry out research to help us discover more and more women artists!

In a nutshell

Historical research continues to identify works created by women.

7
Things are moving forward
Fortunately, things have improved since the 20th century…

…and stories of women artists are increasing. Let’s go to the Middle East to learn about three women who have some things to say.

Nil Yalter, Topak Ev (The yurt),
1973, metal structure, felt, sheepskins, leather, text and mixed techniques, 3 m, © Courtesy santralistanbul Collection

Turkish artist Nil Yater, in the 1970s, discovered that the nomads of the Anatolian steppes were forcefully settled and thus their traditions were threatened.

 

Here, she reinterprets one of their tents, traditionally constructed and decorated by women.

 

Her objective? To raise awareness about issues related to nomadism as well as exile.

Yto Barrada, Girl in Red, Tangier from A Life Full of Holes: The Strait Project,
1999, chromogenic print, 124 x 124 cm, International Center of Photography, New York

The Franco-Moroccan artist Yto Barrada quickly becomes aware that her dual nationality provides her with a privileged freedom of movement, unlike many Moroccans who dream of a greener elsewhere…

 

This may be the case of this woman who turns away from the photographer, her silhouette standing out against a background made up of traditional Moroccan patterns.

Raeda Sa’adeh, Vacuum,
2007, 49 Nord 6 Est – Frac Lorraine collection, Metz (FR). Photo: Raeda Sa’adeh, © R. Sa’adeh
The Palestinian artist Raeda Sa’adeh stages herself here by absurdly subverting a stereotype, that of a woman vacuuming.
The photo is taken in the mountains around Jericho, thus evoking the question of territory in this region contested by Palestinians and Israelis.
In a nutshell

Since the 20th century, more women have gained professional artist status and reappropriated representations of women.

In summary, you have discovered:

  • Many depictions of women, few women artists…
  • Passive models?
  • Representations of musicians and dancers: a reality that truly existed
  • Vice and virtue in the practice of music
  • The role of benefactors
  • Few names of women artists are known to us, but history is not set in stone…
  • Things are moving forward
To train

What proportion of works found in museum collections were produced by women (approximately)?

You have to choose an answer

The sistrum is…

You have to choose an answer

Who was nicknamed the “First Lady of the Renaissance”?

You have to choose an answer

You have opened the final quiz on Women in Art in the Mediterranean.

Knowledge quiz

It’s your turn now!

Answer these 12 questions to check your knowledge. You need to get 10 correct answers to receive your badge.

But there’s no need to panic: if you fail, you can always try again later.

take the quiz